Yet another Minicon poll - The unexamined life
Yet another Minicon poll|
Which version of the Guests of Honor list do you prefer?
The version in the News section of the Minicon 50 home page:
Minicon main page: Our Guests of Honor will be authors Jane Yolen, Larry Niven, and Brandon Sanderson; musician Adam Stemple, and artist Michael Whelan.
Minicon 50 home page subheading: With Jane Yolen, Larry Niven, Brandon Sanderson, Adam Stemple and Tom Doherty.
Minicon 50 home page sub-subheading: The guests of honor will be author Jane Yolen, author Larry Niven, author Brandon Sanderson, Musician Adam Stemple and publisher Tom Doherty.
Minicon 50 home page News section: We are proud to announce the Minicon 50 guests of honor: author Jane Yolen, author Larry Niven, author Brandon Sanderson, Musician Adam Stemple and publisher Tom Doherty.
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 11:15 am (UTC)|| |
Simple reason: Adam is at Minicon 50 as musician GoH, but he does not stop being an author (Jane does not stop being a poet, editor, etc.) for the duration of the con.
I'm somewhat torn between the first version, that lists Michael Whelan but not Tom Doherty, and the second version, that lists Tom Doherty but not Michael Whelan. I really don't like the third or fourth versions which capitalize Musician but don't capitalize author or publisher. I'm poor enough at punctuation that I really can't comment on such things as the use of colon, semicolon, and commas (serial or otherwise).
Edited at 2014-05-20 11:27 am (UTC)
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 11:28 am (UTC)|| |
I do not have an art focus, so I didn't notice what should have been Michael Whelan's conspicuous absence. Why can't there be another version with similar phrasing but listing all GoHs?
I'm fairly certain that Michael Whelan is missing from the Minicon 50 home page because he was a later addition and the Minicon 50 webmaster just hasn't gotten around to adding him. I'm uncertain why Tom Doherty is missing from the GoH list on the main Minicon page.
If you're asking why I don't have a version listing all GoHs in the poll it's because I'm only using the versions on the Minicon page and the Minicon 50 home page.
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 11:37 am (UTC)|| |
More versions! More versions for everyone! Let confusion reign!
I suppose I could have added the version from the Minicon 50 registration form:
Author Guests of Honor: Jane Yolen, Larry Niven, Brandon Sanderson
Musician Guest of Honor: Adam Stemple
Artist Guest of Honor: Michael Whelan
Publisher Guest of Honor: Tom Doherty
At least that version lists all of the GoHs.
And an almost fanatical devotion to the Pope.
I do have an art focus. Michael Whelan should be listed in any version we post.
I wonder about the order of listing. Should authors be listed alphabetically by first or last name? in order of seniority? in order of prominence on some market list? Is this presently random?
Author, Musician, Editor, etc. should all be capitalized.
I also don't seem to be awake enough to get a poll or comment correct on the first try.
But if he's at M50 as musician GoH, then why shouldn't we list him like that instead of as "with"?
Along these lines, if he wants to be listed as Fan GoH or author GoH or fan/author/musician GoH, I'd be fine with any of those. We flapped back and forth during M49 as to whether Janny was an artist GoH or an artist/author GoH because we were trying to list her as she wanted to be listed (and were having some trouble figuring that out).
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 02:47 pm (UTC)|| |
Musician GoH Adam Stemple would be fine with me. Musician Adam Stemple, meh, I don't like that as well.
I see. That's pretty subtle and I'm not sure I can bring myself to worry about it on a regular basis. If it bothers Adam exactly how we lay the words out, we'll certainly change it, of course.
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 06:06 pm (UTC)|| |
Makes sense. It's certainly not to the level that I would have approached the concom about it, but once it was there on my friendslist saying, "Which do you like best?", that's why I liked that best.
Apologies to all for the odd "The version in the News section of the Minicon 50 home page:" in the poll. It's left over from a previous attempt to post the poll and I can't figure out how to edit a poll once it's been posted.
Something haz changed, there ain't no way...
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 11:55 am (UTC)|| |
The inconsistencies drive me nuts, but someone could point them out to the MInicon webmaster or whomever. Maybe once we settle on the best one. ;-p
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 12:03 pm (UTC)|| |
Needs serial comma, whatever it is. Dangit.
Your various options differ in more than one way from each other and I'm not clear on what "main page" implies as opposed to "home page sub-heading", so I didn't tick a box. Here are some of my opinions that can be used to prefer one option over another in various conflicting ways:
I would prefer they be listed as "guest of honor" and not "with".
I'm not big into being "proud to announce".
I don't think it matters whether it says "author" separately in front of each author or whether authors are given as a list with "author" said only once.
I don't think that GoH should be listed only as "news", since they are permanent.
What's the motivation of this poll?
Oh, reading the comments I see it's because we have all of them at once.
I know you know this, but it would be much more effective to directly say this to me or Joe. We aren't some faceless entity, and would/will actually fix problems as they are pointed out.
|Date:||May 20th, 2014 10:24 pm (UTC)|| |
I suggest a "Webmaster" link at the bottom of the page.
It may not be known who the web maintainers are by name, and communication skills vary widely within the most known members of the concom.
On the MN-StF page, list Minicon 50 and the names of the GoH's. The current Minicon page is okay, but probably needs updating. The current Minicon 50 page is redundant but not specific. The names are listed twice, but their GoHdom is not specified.
I also wish you would emphasize, in one or more of these places, that Minicon 50 will be a Big Deal, and we're encouraging former GoHs and, indeed, all former attendees to come.